Top 8 Most Valuable Silver Coins in the World

Top 8 Most Valuable Silver Coins in the World

Theories on the origin of money are widely divided among historians, economists, and anthropologists. It is popularly known that mankind began trading by simply exchanging goods for goods and some experts believe that early forms of currency (such as shells, live cattle, or even precious metal ingots) were spontaneously used by common people in order to solve bartering disputes.

Others believe, however, that the earliest form of money originated in Mesopotamia (modern-day Iraq) around 5,000 years ago. Using standardized weights of silver, the rulers used to measure wages, taxes, and fines, as well as set debts between two trading parties.

As millennia went by, local governments, especially in Lydia and Ancient Greece, started stamping specific amounts of silver in order to dismiss the need of weighing the metal every time a trade occurred, thus creating the first silver coins.

For thousands of years, a bimetallic standard of monetary system that used a fixed ratio of silver and gold as units of currency spread around the world, including in the newly independent United States of America. 

The Coinage Act of 1792, passed by the US Congress, established the creation of the Philadelphia Mint and specified designs and the ways of production for copper, silver, and gold coins, basically laying down the foundation of American currency.

However, in contemporary society, the gold and silver standard could not withstand the inflation and debasement of currencies, which led the way to the creation of a form of money that wasn’t backed by any commodity, known as fiat currency. In the United States, it occurred in 1971 when President Nixon introduced a law to abandon the direct convertibility of the U.S. dollar into gold.

All these changes in monetary policies, along with the fact that the coins in this list were able to survive the test of time and were around, in circulation, during war and peace, prosperity and economic crises, are the key factors to why they are so valued by collectors and numismatists. 

The whole list below is made of coins composed of a majority of silver that were actually sold at an auction before and include both the most expensive coins in the United States and the world.

Note that only one specimen of each coin is included in the list, in spite of others having been sold by expressive amounts as well. For instance, many specimens of the 1804 Bust Dollar were sold at incredible prices, but only the highest-selling one was included in the list.

8. 1870 S Seated Liberty Dollar: $1,092,250

 1870 S Seated Liberty Dollar

Source: https://www.pcgs.com

The Seated Liberty was a design used by the US Mint for the Dollar coin from 1840 to 1873. It depicted, on the obverse, the female figure Liberty seated on a boulder. She is holding a liberty pole topped with a pileus on her left hand while resting a 13-striped shield (representing the thirteen original colonies) on the floor, next to her, with her right hand. The portrait is outlined by thirteen 6-pointed stars.

As stellar as the design may be, however, it was not the reason why this coin sold for $ 1,092,250 at an auction in May of 2003.

All silver coins prior to 1870 are pretty rare on their own, not just because they are old, but because many of these coins were melted down after the California Gold Rush. At the time, gold prices dropped as low as the price of silver, and people started hoarding silver coins for their intrinsic value. In 1873, Congress would pass another Coinage Act ending bimetallism in the US and temporarily establishing the gold standard in the country.

On top of that, the 1870 Seated Liberty Silver Dollar with the San Francisco mark has a story of its own. Until that year, the silver dollars were minted exclusively in the Philadelphia Mint. That year, though, they were also minted in Carson City and San Francisco. However, no one really knows how the San Francisco Mint got the obverse dies for the production of the 1870 silver dollar, nor how many were actually produced there, as there are no records of the US Mint sending them the dies, nor records of that years’ silver dollar mintage in San Francisco.

And thus, the mysterious existence of the 1870-S Silver Dollar and its rarity combined was the cause for its outstanding achieved bid price.

7. 1797 Draped Bust Half-Dollar: $1,527,500

1797 Draped Bust Half-Dollar

Source: https://www.pcgs.com

In 1796, by popular demand, the US Congress commissioned the creation of a new design for the half-dollar piece. The Draped Bust, designed by Robert Scot, was first issued in 1797, replacing the “Flowing Hair” design.

It featured the bust of allegorical female figure Liberty with draped hair with the word Liberty on top and the mint year on the bottom, with fifteen six-pointed stars on the outer rim.

The reverse was engraved with what came to be known as the “small eagle” design, which was scrapped in 1798, making this 1797 version of the half-dollar, very rare to obtain.

A specimen was sold in 2015 for $1,527,500.

6.  1894-S Barber dime: $1,997,500

1894-S Barber dime

Source: https://www.pcgs.com

One of the most sought-after American silver coins is the 1894-S Dime. Only 24 of these proof coins were minted in San Francisco that year. Why only 24? Nobody knows for certain. One theory is that the superintendent of the San Francisco Mint ordered their production with the intent to gift them to important bankers.

Legend says the superintendent gave three of these coins to his daughter and that she spent one of them in a dish of ice cream and sold the other two in the 1950s.

Both sides of this coin were designed by Charles E. Barber, hence the name Barber Dimes.

Only 9 of the mintage is known to have survived to the present day. The highest-selling specimen, graded Proof 66 by PCGS, sold at $1,997,500 in January of 2016.

Curious about the most expensive gold coins in the world? Check them here!

5. 409/6 BC Decadrachm: $2,918,000

409/6 BC Decadrachm

Symbolic picture of a decadrachm. Source: https://en.numista.com

The Ancient Greeks were one of the precursors in the making of silver coins. For centuries, their monetary system was silver-based with their drachma, which weighed 4.3 grams of silver (in the Attic standard). The decadrachm weighed 43 grams of silver and was worth 10 pieces of the drachma. 

This specimen belonged to the collection of oil executive Nelson Bunker Hunt, whose attempt in the early 1980s to corner the silver market eventually caused it to collapse.

This masterpiece of classical style was engraved circa 409 to 406 BC and was sold for $2,918,000 in October of 2012.

4. 1704 Ivan VI Pattern Silver Rouble, Russia: $3,858,850

1704 Ivan VI Pattern Silver Rouble Obverse1704 Ivan VI Pattern Silver Rouble Reverse

Source: https://en.numista.com

The Rouble (or Ruble) was the currency used in the Russian Empire and the name is still used for the current Russian Federation. It has been used for the Russian territories since the 14th century.

Only two specimens of the 1704 Silver Rouble are known to still exist and it fetched the whopping amount of $3,858,850 at a public auction in 2012, a record for any Russian coin. 

The lettering on the obverse of this Red Mint product states “Tsar Pyotr Alexeyevich Ruler of the whole Russia”, and the translation of the reverse is “Good coin, price - ruble 1704”.

3. 1885 Trade Dollar: $3,960,000

1885 Trade Dollar

Source: https://www.pcgs.com

Trade coins were, essentially, quasi-bullion coins that could be used as export goods. In other words, they were used in international trades to import goods.

The Coinage Act, passed by Congress in 1873, approved the issuance of trade dollars (that were also legal tender inside the country). Business strikes were only produced until 1875, but the Mint kept producing proof versions until 1885. However, only five examples of the 1885 Trade Dollar were actually minted, and, for over twenty years, they were thought to not exist at all. All five samples are still known to exist.

Trade Dollars were re-monetized by the Coinage Act of 1965. Both verses of the coin were embellished by designs created by William Barber, Mint Chief Engraver from 1869 until his death in 1879.

One specimen amounted to $3,960,000 at an auction in January of 2019.

2. 1804 Bust Dollar - Class I: $4,140,000

1804 Bust Dollar - Class I

Source: https://www.pcgs.com

The story of the 1804 Bust Dollar (also known as the Bowed Liberty) is full of mystery and confusion. First of all, in spite of being dated 1804, they were actually minted in 1834 or later. They were, initially, intended to be given away as gifts by diplomat Edmund Roberts on his diplomatic trips to Siam, Muscat, Japan, and Conchinchina. 

These coins, produced by the Mint for diplomatic purposes, are known as the Class I 1804 Bust Dollars. They went unnoticed by the numismatist community until 1842, when a publication, signed by two Mint employees, showed a picture of one of these silver coins.

By popular demand, Mint officials in 1843 covertly produced several more examples of the coin, but they were struck with incorrect edge lettering. These strikes came to be known as the Class II 1804 Bust Dollars. More examples would later be released by the Mint bearing the correct original edge lettering, and those last coins are called Class III 1804 Bust Dollars.

Only fifteen specimens, from Class I, II and III, are known to still exist and they have sold by millions of dollars at auctions. However, the highest-selling specimen was a Class I sold in 1999 with the incredible amount of $4,140,000.

1. 1794 Flowing Hair Dollar: $10 million

1794 Flowing Hair Dollar

Source: https://www.pcgs.com

Until 1792 all circulating coins struck in America were done so by private refiners under the regulation of each individual State. However, that changed when the United States Federal Government, led by President George Washington, urged Congress to create a unified coinage system and a national Mint.

Congress responded on April 2nd of 1792, by passing the Coinage Act which created the US Mint’s first branch in Philadelphia (at the time, the nation’s Capital).

Mintage began slowly in the newly established three-story refinery in Philadelphia as Mint employees lacked the experience in designing and engraving of coins, and the operations were initially done with a crude horse or man-powered machinery.

Still, the first copper coins were produced in 1793 for the half-cent and cent denominations.  The following year, silver mintage would begin for the half-dime, dime, quarter, half-dollar, and dollar denominations.

The 1794 Silver Dollar is, therefore, the first-ever US Dollar coin to be officially minted and issued by the United States Mint and it was based on the Spanish dollar (at the time, already largely in use in the country).

A 1794 Flowing Hair Dollar was sold at an auction in January of 2013 by the record amount of $10,016,875 and it is, still to this day, the most expensive coin ever sold, including gold coins.

← Previous Next →
Chase Turner
Chase Turner

Chase has been buying and selling gold, silver and platinum since 2009, when he opened a local gold shop. He fell in love with buying gold and silver bullion after learning how the world monetary system works and has been an avid believer and preacher of hard assets ever since. 

He has worked in various levels and sectors within the precious metals industry and has consulted thousands of precious metals investors on the best way to buy and sell bullion at all levels...